Assessment over Assurance: SEBI's Pragmatic Recalibration of BRSR Value Chain Disclosures
[Mokshit is a student at Gujarat National Law University.]
Sustainability reporting in India has moved from voluntary narrative to verified data within a single regulatory cycle. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) required the top 1,000 listed entities by market capitalisation to file a Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report (BRSR) under Regulation 34(2)(f) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations 2015 (listing regulations), and in July 2023 added the BRSR Core, a subset of key performance indicators subject to third-party verification, together with a framework extending ESG disclosure into the value chain. The design assumed that a listed buyer could obtain audit-grade data from suppliers that owe no reporting duty under securities law. SEBI's circular of 28 March 2025 tested that assumption and retreated from it. This piece argues that the retreat is sound regulatory pragmatism, because it spares small suppliers a verification burden their systems cannot yet carry, but that it will work only if three gaps are closed: contractual cascading of a nominally voluntary regime, uneven verification quality, and the absence of a common supplier data standard.
The March 2025 Recalibration
The circular made three adjustments. First, it replaced assurance with a choice between assessment and assurance for the BRSR Core, assessment being a third-party exercise conducted against standards developed by the Industry Standards Forum in consultation with SEBI. Second, it deferred value chain ESG disclosures by a year and made them voluntary for the top 250 listed entities from FY 2025-26, in place of the earlier comply-or-explain position. Third, it confined the relevant value chain to upstream and downstream partners that individually account for 2% or more of purchases or sales, with assessment or assurance of those disclosures voluntary from FY 2026-27. The glide path for the listed entities' own BRSR Core data was left intact, so the top 1,000 entities must still obtain verification in FY 2026-27. The table below summarises the shift.
Element | July 2023 framework | March 2025 circular |
BRSR Core verification | Assurance | Assessment or assurance |
Value chain disclosure (top 250) | Comply or explain, deferred to FY 2025-26 | Voluntary from FY 2025-26 |
Value chain verification | Comply or explain | Voluntary from FY 2026-27 |
Why Proportionality is Defensible
Matching verification burden to supplier capacity
A small supplier asked for emissions, water withdrawal and waste data confronts a problem of infrastructure rather than willingness. The asymmetry is sharper for micro and small enterprises, which often lack dedicated sustainability staff and may rely on a single owner-manager for compliance decisions. Metering, record-keeping and calculation methodologies take time and money to build, and a supplier serving several listed buyers may face several uncoordinated requests. Had verification been mandatory, assurance would have operated as a condition of market access, shifting a regulatory cost from listed entities, which can bear it, to unlisted firms, which cannot. A voluntary regime lets data coverage grow with supplier capacity, and the 2% threshold concentrates attention on partners whose data moves the listed entity's own footprint most.
Widening the verification market
The substitution of assessment for assurance matters beyond the value chain. Assurance engagements follow established professional standards and are ordinarily led by audit firms. Assessment against Industry Standards Forum standards is a different exercise, and the circular requires the provider to hold the necessary expertise rather than a particular professional qualification. On its face, this opens verification of metrics such as greenhouse gas emissions and water consumption to technical specialists, including energy auditors and environmental engineers, which should enlarge the supply of verifiers and temper fees for entities entering the regime.
Frictions the Relaxation Leaves Unresolved
The contractual cascade
Voluntariness in regulation does not guarantee voluntariness in commerce. A listed entity that elects to report value chain data will collect it through procurement terms, and a small supplier negotiating with a large buyer has little room to refuse. Fragmentation compounds the problem, because each buyer may prescribe its own format, leaving a supplier to reconcile several questionnaires that seek overlapping but non-identical data. Lenders, investors and ESG raters add pressure from the other side, since disclosure that peers make becomes an expectation that laggards must explain. The likely outcome is a regime voluntary for the top 250 and de facto compulsory for their suppliers, without the procedural safeguards that accompany binding regulation. The burden SEBI removed formally may return through contract.
Verification quality and comparability
Flexibility carries a cost in comparability. Assurance and assessment differ in rigour, and a reader of a BRSR cannot assume that two entities' verified figures rest on equivalent work. The circular partly addresses this by requiring the report to name the provider and state the type of verification obtained, but a label does not disclose scope, sampling or the standard applied. Without further transparency, assessment risks becoming a cheaper signal that markets cannot distinguish from assurance, inviting the greenwashing the BRSR Core was designed to deter.
A grace period already spent
The FY 2025-26 window for voluntary value chain disclosure closed on 31 March 2026. Entities that used it to map suppliers and test data collection hold an advantage, while others enter FY 2026-27 without preparatory infrastructure. The consequence is uneven readiness across the top 250, which will surface as inconsistent data quality once investors begin comparing value chain coverage. Regulatory patience yields value only when regulated entities use it.
Concrete Reform Proposals
Four measures would convert the circular's flexibility into durable policy. First, SEBI, working through the Industry Standards Forum, should prescribe a single short-form supplier template confined to a handful of BRSR Core indicators, namely energy, water, waste and greenhouse gas emissions, which any partner could complete once and furnish to every listed buyer. A common template removes duplicative requests and gives small suppliers a fixed compliance target.
Second, SEBI should issue guidance that a listed entity reporting value chain data voluntarily must accept the standard template from partners below a stated turnover band and must not condition continued engagement on third-party verification of that data. A BRSR disclosure stating whether value chain figures are primary data or estimates would make compliance observable to investors.
Third, good-faith estimation should be protected. Where a supplier cannot yet measure a metric, a listed entity should be permitted to report a modelled estimate, provided that the methodology and its limits are disclosed, with a safe harbour against regulatory action for inaccuracies arising from data the entity could not reasonably have verified. Such a rule treats estimation as a transitional practice rather than a violation.
Fourth, the assessment route needs a quality architecture. The Industry Standards Forum should publish competence criteria for assessment providers and maintain a public register of them, while the BRSR should state the scope and standard applied, so that readers can tell assessment from assurance in substance and not merely by name. Any later move from voluntary to mandatory value chain reporting should follow a published review of data coverage, cost and supplier experience after the FY 2026-27 cycle, rather than a fixed calendar date.
Listed entities need not await these reforms. Preparation should begin with a supplier master register mapped to the 2% threshold, followed by integration of ESG data fields into procurement and enterprise resource planning systems, and onboarding of key suppliers through a short standardised questionnaire with reasonable timelines. Entities that digitise supplier data now will absorb any future mandate at lower marginal cost.
Conclusion
The March 2025 circular is best read as a calibration of pace rather than a dilution of ambition. By allowing assessment alongside assurance and making value chain reporting voluntary, SEBI has aligned its timetable with the data capacity of unlisted suppliers. Yet the measure is pragmatic only if voluntariness survives contact with procurement practice and flexibility in verification does not erode comparability. A common supplier template, protection for good-faith estimates, restraint in contractual cascading and a transparent register of verifiers would secure both objectives, and would allow SEBI to extend the regime on evidence rather than assumption. Regulatory flexibility is a means of sequencing, not a substitute for eventual rigour.